.png)
✔ Independent Insurance Agent ✔ Serving Niagara County, NY ✔ Multiple Top-Rated Carriers ✔ Local, Personalized Service
Auto, Home & Small Business Insurance
from a Local Agent Who Works for You
AUTO - Auto Insurance in Niagara County
​
We compare policies from multiple carriers to find the right auto insurance coverage for your needs and budget.
HOME - Home Owners Insurance in Niagara County
​
Protect your home, rental property, or investment with coverage designed for Niagara County homeowners.
BUSINESS - Business Insurance in Niagara County, NY
​
Customized insurance solutions for small businesses, including liability, commercial auto, and workers’ compensation.
At Paul Hutchins Agency, we help individuals, families, and small businesses throughout Niagara County, NY find reliable insurance coverage at competitive rates. As an independent insurance agency, we work with multiple insurance carriers so we can focus on what’s best for you — not one company. When you call us, you speak directly with a local agent, not a call center.
CALL FOR A FREE QUOTE AND
TALK TO AN AGENT NOW
716-405-7420
​
Why Clients Choose Paul Hutchins Insurance Agency
​
We believe insurance should feel personal, not overwhelming. As an independent, locally owned agency, we take the time to understand your needs and help you choose coverage that truly fits.
What you can expect:
-
Access to multiple insurance carriers for more options and flexibility
-
Coverage tailored to your life, family, or business—not a one-size-fits-all policy
-
A local team you can reach when questions arise or life changes
What Client's Are Saying...
Niagara Sports Cards
Paul has been very good to us with our Business and our Home insurances. He always goes out of his way for us. He'll even call me if he sees I can save money in ways. Paul is a top notch stand up guy. I trust him 100% with our insurance needs.
Lisa L.
Paul is absolutely the BEST! I've never worked with a broker before. He is your go to guy. He got me a great bundle for my auto/home. Saved me nearly $1000 a yr. I was nervous switching. Paul made everything so easy. Communication was outstanding. If your looking to save $, Paul is your guy!!!Thanks again for all your work. Much appreciated😊
Thomas P.
I can't say enough great things about Paul Hutchins Insurance Agency! Paul and his team have been absolutely amazing in handling both my home and car insurance. Anytime I have a question or need assistance, Paul is always available and ready to help. Their team is fast, efficient, and truly looks out for their customers, making sure we have the best coverage at the best price. I love that they take the time to find the right policies that fit our family budget without sacrificing quality. If you’re looking for an insurance agency that genuinely cares, Paul Hutchins Insurance Agency is the one to trust!